共和党吸引低- IQ voters

美国新闻时事讨论


版主: resso

内容
作者
头像
fortyNiner
中坚
帖子: 635
注册时间: 2023-12-21
Has thanked: 5 time
Been thanked: 46 time

Re: 共和党吸引低- IQ voters

#21

#21 帖子 fortyNiner »

What is my analysis method?
I used data you provided.
What's wrong with my method?
In your previous post, you doubted the data you provided, now you are redirecting to my method?

小河清流 写了: 16 3月 2024, 19:04
fortyNiner 写了: 16 3月 2024, 19:01

Then why did you provide your source since you don't trust it?

I point out you analysis method is invalid, so the result is not reliable.

 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

头像
小河清流
精英
帖子: 2034
注册时间: 2023-12-21
Has thanked: 20 time
Been thanked: 63 time

Re: 共和党吸引低- IQ voters

#22

#22 帖子 小河清流 »

fortyNiner 写了: 16 3月 2024, 19:05

What is my analysis method?
I used data you provided.
What's wrong with my method?
In your previous post, you doubted the data you provided, now you are redirecting to my method?

小河清流 写了: 16 3月 2024, 19:04

I point out you analysis method is invalid, so the result is not reliable.

For example, data did not include illegal immigrant which most in the southwest , poverty level , blue/red populate within states, all those can be factors.

 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

头像
fortyNiner
中坚
帖子: 635
注册时间: 2023-12-21
Has thanked: 5 time
Been thanked: 46 time

Re: 共和党吸引低- IQ voters

#23

#23 帖子 fortyNiner »

So you are saying the data you provided are flawed? Then why did you use it to try to refute me?
If it turned out that your data supported your claim, would you still stand with it?

小河清流 写了: 16 3月 2024, 19:10
fortyNiner 写了: 16 3月 2024, 19:05

What is my analysis method?
I used data you provided.
What's wrong with my method?
In your previous post, you doubted the data you provided, now you are redirecting to my method?

For example, data did not include illegal immigrant which most in the southwest , poverty level , blue/red populate within states, all those can be factors.

 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

上次由 fortyNiner 在 16 3月 2024, 19:16,总共编辑 1 次。
头像
小河清流
精英
帖子: 2034
注册时间: 2023-12-21
Has thanked: 20 time
Been thanked: 63 time

Re: 共和党吸引低- IQ voters

#24

#24 帖子 小河清流 »

I said your interpretation is flawed. I only said the data doesn't support your conclusion.

 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

头像
fortyNiner
中坚
帖子: 635
注册时间: 2023-12-21
Has thanked: 5 time
Been thanked: 46 time

Re: 共和党吸引低- IQ voters

#25

#25 帖子 fortyNiner »

What's wrong with my interpretation?
Multiple each state's rate to its population, add them up, then divide the sum by the total population. That gives you the overall average of each group of states. What's wrong with it?
You are not consistent. In some posts, you said my interpretation/analysis was flawed. In some other, you said the data was not completed. What exactly did you mean?

小河清流 写了: 16 3月 2024, 19:16

I said your interpretation is flawed. I only said the data doesn't support your conclusion.

 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

头像
小河清流
精英
帖子: 2034
注册时间: 2023-12-21
Has thanked: 20 time
Been thanked: 63 time

Re: 共和党吸引低- IQ voters

#26

#26 帖子 小河清流 »

fortyNiner 写了: 16 3月 2024, 19:20

What's wrong with my interpretation?
Multiple each state's rate to its population, add them up, then divide the sum by the total population. That gives you the overall average of each group of states. What's wrong with it?
You are not consistent. In some posts, you said my interpretation/analysis was flawed. In some other, you said the data was not completed. What exactly did you mean?

小河清流 写了: 16 3月 2024, 19:16

I said your interpretation is flawed. I only said the data doesn't support your conclusion.

you make a statement , your slice the data , you have to proof it , complete it . my data don't need slice , shows blue is on top. I don't need to lecture you on scientific method, right?

 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

头像
fortyNiner
中坚
帖子: 635
注册时间: 2023-12-21
Has thanked: 5 time
Been thanked: 46 time

Re: 共和党吸引低- IQ voters

#27

#27 帖子 fortyNiner »

We are talking about the overall average. I never deny that there are many shithole cities in blue states, Cal included. It's also possible that the most shithole places are in blue states. I am not talking about this in this thread. I am talking that on average, red states have higher crime rate, which is supported by the data you provided.
Using YOUR data, I showed that red states have 8% higher crime rates. And then you said the data is invalid because it might be incomplete? If you are able to, show how my analysis is flawed, instaed of just "I don't need to lecture you on scientific method".

小河清流 写了: 16 3月 2024, 19:32
fortyNiner 写了: 16 3月 2024, 19:20

What's wrong with my interpretation?
Multiple each state's rate to its population, add them up, then divide the sum by the total population. That gives you the overall average of each group of states. What's wrong with it?
You are not consistent. In some posts, you said my interpretation/analysis was flawed. In some other, you said the data was not completed. What exactly did you mean?

you make a statement , your slice the data , you have to proof it , complete it . my data don't need slice , shows blue is on top. I don't need to lecture you on scientific method, right?

 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

头像
小河清流
精英
帖子: 2034
注册时间: 2023-12-21
Has thanked: 20 time
Been thanked: 63 time

Re: 共和党吸引低- IQ voters

#28

#28 帖子 小河清流 »

once you slice the data , YOU NEED to provide more data to support your conclusion. I can play the game all day long and lead to a slice that support my view point.

 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

头像
fortyNiner
中坚
帖子: 635
注册时间: 2023-12-21
Has thanked: 5 time
Been thanked: 46 time

Re: 共和党吸引低- IQ voters

#29

#29 帖子 fortyNiner »

Slice data? What did I do to slice data?
I used every single bit of the data you provided.

小河清流 写了: 16 3月 2024, 19:53

once you slice the data , YOU NEED to provide more data to support your conclusion. I can play the game all day long and lead to a slice that support my view point.

 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

回复