美国总统的收入是否应该公开?

美国新闻时事讨论


版主: resso

回复
内容
作者
shepherd17
精英
帖子: 5798
注册时间: 2023-12-24
Has thanked: 947 time
Been thanked: 792 time

美国总统的收入是否应该公开?

#1

#1 帖子 shepherd17 »

自愿传统 vs. 法律权利: 自吉米·卡特以来,美国总统通常会自愿公开其报税表以建立公众信任,但从法律上讲,他们有权享有隐私,国税局(IRS)也被禁止公开这些资料。

利益冲突的缓解: 公开的报税表(例如唐纳德·特朗普最终公布的 2015–2020 年报税表)让公众能够判断总统是否利用职权增加个人财富。

“尼克松规则”: 正如前总统尼克松所说:“人民必须知道他们的总统是不是个骗子。”这强调了透明度在维持公众信任中的重要作用。

立法行动: 例如《2021 年人民法案》(For the People Act of 2021)等立法提案,要求总统、副总统及候选人公开数年的报税表。

现行规定: 总统已经被要求提交年度财务报告,这些报告由 OpenSecrets 公开展示,披露资产、收入类型以及超过特定门槛的负债。

目前,公开税表仍是一种政治惯例,而非法律要求,但它通常被视为政府透明度的重要组成部分。


Voluntary Tradition vs. Legal Rights: While, since Jimmy Carter, presidents voluntarily released their returns to build trust, they are legally entitled to privacy, and the IRS is barred from releasing them.

Conflict of Interest Mitigation: Public returns, such as the ones eventually released by Donald Trump covering 2015-2020, allow citizens to see if a president is using the office to increase personal wealth.

The "Nixon Rule": As former President Nixon stated, "People have got to know whether or not their president is a crook," highlighting the role of transparency in maintaining public trust.

Legislative Action: Legislation, such as the For the People Act of 2021, has been proposed to require the public disclosure of several years of tax returns for presidents, vice presidents, and candidates.

Existing Regulations: The President is already required to file annual financial reports, which are handled by OpenSecrets for public viewing. These disclose assets, income types, and liabilities above certain thresholds.

Currently, public tax disclosure is a political norm rather than a legal requirement, though it is often considered a critical component of government transparency.

 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

头像
Lilyamao
栋梁
帖子: 14136
注册时间: 2023-12-24
Has thanked: 154 time
Been thanked: 783 time

Re: 美国总统的收入是否应该公开?

#2

#2 帖子 Lilyamao »

所以拜登已经立法总统要公开税表

老川认为2021年前没立法,所以IRS🈶员工公布塔的纳税数字非法

老川要钱要疯了

 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

shepherd17
精英
帖子: 5798
注册时间: 2023-12-24
Has thanked: 947 time
Been thanked: 792 time

Re: 美国总统的收入是否应该公开?

#3

#3 帖子 shepherd17 »

特朗普在任期间为什么不愿公开自己的收入?

关于特朗普为何不愿公开其报税表,媒体报道和调查总结了几个主要原因:

  1. 他多次声称自己正接受国税局审计
    报道指出,特朗普“多次声称由于正在接受国税局审计,因此无法公开报税表”,但审计并不会阻止个人自愿公开自己的税表。

  2. 采取法律行动阻止公开
    在国会寻求获取其税务记录时,特朗普曾提起诉讼,试图阻止国税局和其会计师事务所向州政府或国会提供相关文件。

  3. 担心声誉或财务方面的影响
    在部分税务信息泄露后,特朗普在诉讼中表示,泄露可能导致“声誉和财务损害”,并带来“公众尴尬”。泄露的文件显示,他在某些年份缴纳的联邦所得税金额非常低。

  4. 长期存在的税务争议
    已公开的部分税务信息显示,他使用了大量亏损和税务策略来减少税负,这些内容引发了更多政治和法律层面的关注。

  5. 打破了总统公开税表的长期惯例
    过去几十年,美国总统通常会自愿公开税表,而特朗普选择不公开,使得公众和国会更加关注其财务状况。


Donald Trump’s unwillingness to disclose his tax returns has been widely discussed, and multiple sources outline several key reasons—some stated by Trump himself, others raised by analysts and investigators.

Core Reasons Trump Did Not Release His Tax Returns

1. Claim of Being Under IRS Audit
Trump repeatedly stated that he could not release his tax returns because they were under audit. However, reporting notes that IRS audits do not legally prevent a taxpayer from voluntarily releasing their own returns. This made many observers view the audit explanation as a convenient justification rather than a legal barrier. Wikipedia factually.co

2. Political Strategy and Self‑Protection
Analysts argue that withholding the returns was a calculated political move. By not releasing them, Trump avoided potential political damage from disclosures about his finances, tax strategies, or liabilities. This became especially relevant after media reports revealed he had paid very little in federal income tax in certain years. factually.co

3. Concerns About Revealing Aggressive Tax Practices
Investigations and reporting suggested that Trump’s tax returns might show extensive tax‑minimization strategies, large losses, or other financial vulnerabilities. These concerns gained traction after leaked documents showed unusually low tax payments. factually.co

4. Legal Battles to Prevent Disclosure
Trump actively fought in court to block the IRS, his accountants, and Congress from obtaining or releasing his tax records. These legal efforts continued for years, indicating a strong desire to keep the documents private. Wikipedia

5. Aftermath of Leaks and Lawsuits
When portions of his tax information were leaked, Trump sued the IRS and Treasury Department for failing to prevent the unauthorized release. This reinforced the idea that he viewed disclosure as harmful to his reputation or finances. NBC News

 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

shepherd17
精英
帖子: 5798
注册时间: 2023-12-24
Has thanked: 947 time
Been thanked: 792 time

Re: 美国总统的收入是否应该公开?

#4

#4 帖子 shepherd17 »

Lilyamao 写了: 19 4月 2026, 21:24

所以拜登已经立法总统要公开税表

老川认为2021年前没立法,所以IRS🈶员工公布塔的纳税数字非法

老川要钱要疯了

不管川总怎么做,他都是爱国的。反对川总就是反美国。

 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

头像
dragonfly
精英
帖子: 2914
注册时间: 2025-05-08
Has thanked: 80 time
Been thanked: 275 time

Re: 美国总统的收入是否应该公开?

#5

#5 帖子 dragonfly »

还是没回答:
IRS员工未经许可透露纳税人私人信息,到底违法吗?
川普起诉违法(假如)IRS员工要求赔偿,违法吗?
就算川普杀人被判了死刑,也没人有权力对川普动用私刑,不是吗?

 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

养老型发言 :D

头像
resso
栋梁
帖子: 22790
注册时间: 2023-12-24
Has thanked: 132 time
Been thanked: 401 time

Re: 美国总统的收入是否应该公开?

#6

#6 帖子 resso »

dragonfly 写了: 19 4月 2026, 22:04

还是没回答:
IRS员工未经许可透露纳税人私人信息,到底违法吗?
川普起诉违法(假如)IRS员工要求赔偿,违法吗?
就算川普杀人被判了死刑,也没人有权力对川普动用私刑,不是吗?

lol,这个irs员工和川总有异曲同工之妙,符合maga的恶人当需恶人磨的世界观

 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

shepherd17
精英
帖子: 5798
注册时间: 2023-12-24
Has thanked: 947 time
Been thanked: 792 time

Re: 美国总统的收入是否应该公开?

#7

#7 帖子 shepherd17 »

dragonfly 写了: 19 4月 2026, 22:04

还是没回答:
IRS员工未经许可透露纳税人私人信息,到底违法吗?
川普起诉违法(假如)IRS员工要求赔偿,违法吗?
就算川普杀人被判了死刑,也没人有权力对川普动用私刑,不是吗?

那是阿毛关注的话题,不是我关注的话题。

 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

头像
Lilyamao
栋梁
帖子: 14136
注册时间: 2023-12-24
Has thanked: 154 time
Been thanked: 783 time

Re: 美国总统的收入是否应该公开?

#8

#8 帖子 Lilyamao »

resso 写了: 19 4月 2026, 22:06
dragonfly 写了: 19 4月 2026, 22:04

还是没回答:
IRS员工未经许可透露纳税人私人信息,到底违法吗?
川普起诉违法(假如)IRS员工要求赔偿,违法吗?
就算川普杀人被判了死刑,也没人有权力对川普动用私刑,不是吗?

lol,这个irs员工和川总有异曲同工之妙,符合maga的恶人当需恶人磨的世界观

其实2021年拜登立法就通过了总统必须披露税表

这是一个迟到的法规

这个IRS员工是英雄,他以自己的入狱推动了美国的民主宪法进程

 

POSTREACT(ions) SUMMARY

回复